After finishing this book I went back to Amazons website and checked my subscriptions and for whatever reason, they didnt have me down, so I had to sign up.again. Im a Stay and Atiny (stan Stray Kids and Ateez yall) who excels at ignoring her TBR. Please keep in mind that any opinions expressed in these outside Blogs are those of their proprietor and not necessarily mine, though I do like to keep things interesting. Shes constantly struggling with how good it feels to draw on the Dark, to not succumb to it. Granted, Katherine (Kate Dickie) was trying to strangle her daughter to death in a deranged and irrational fury, but self-defense is a legal nuance that would probably be alien to a 17th century. . There is a lot of information that leads up to the climax/ending of this book. . So uhmI have no excuses for being so late to the party. Im so glad that the ending of this one has you so excited for the sequel! The plot is not defined and difficult to follow. Unable to add item to List. But Tea finds solace and guidance with an older, wiser bone witch, who takes Tea and her brother to another land for training. Please try your request again later. Of course, she excels in nearly every way with minimal struggle. Ill be honest in that I havent read many books where I can definitively recall the main character being an anti-hero or anti-heroine. Apologies to folks, but I want to put this whole thing in a spoiler link, since it's somewhat spoilerific. Youre the one magically raping someone, you prick. They are represented by Rebecca Podos of the Helen Rees Agency. In case you couldnt tell from the color scheme of my blog, I think purple is pretty rad so I was hopelessly enchanted with this cover. Lovely review! Crying was not on my bingo card for this book. Join. The Bone Witch delivers a perfect mixture of witchy atmosphere, banter-filled fun and lots of sexual tension. Sold by Amazon.com. Im rushing to get books two and three to continue this amazing story.The plot itself was slow, which was another thing that surprised me because I love quickly developing plots and fast paced action in books. Sorry, there was a problem loading this page. And, of course, I invite everyone to the discussion of themes and story of Victory! Read honest and unbiased product reviews . Used only items are excluded in this order but can be purchased from the items detail page. Honestly speaking the ending of The Shadowglass made me feel so many things. Highest insanity. I usually get super attached to POV characters, haha. Its a clever way to weave the two narratives if you will together I think. Born and raised in Manila, Philippines, they keep four pets: a dog, two birds, and a husband. The dark asha are also responsible for raising daevafrom the dead and confiscating theirbezoar before putting them back to rest. , Grade level I dont always know what the pieces of clothing are but Google can save me here. He seems to have gone out of his way to do the . THAT LAST BIT OF DIALOGUE. I found myself greedily reading any information I was given because the information I wanted was withheld. You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition. I didn't see that coming! Meanwhile, when Hodgins' reckless driving gets him and Angela arrested and thrown in jail, Sweets and intern Clark Edison step into . The story is literally being told by Tea in past tense as she explains to Bard her story. Everything else in the post is spoiler free. Halfway Discussion goes live around the middle of each month. I totally wouldnt mind if the sequel had a different character POV, I loved Tea but would likely connect to another character in this world too; its so rich and detailed, I just want to know more about everything! I really loved the pacing of this book, yes its slow and yes we flip to the past I suppose for the majority of the chapters. Tea Pahlavi Fox Pahlavi Facebook Categories However the addition of having present Tea chapters after reliving the past, definitely adds a spark of intrigue to it, youre left with many questions making you continue reading. Although, most of you must be going to my site because this is the first Im hearing of this problem and Ive been doing this for a decent amount of time. Though the series name specifies fantasy, we will read books from all of speculative fiction. Wtf, I knew exactly where this was going. But Tea finds solace and guidance with an older, wiser bone witch, who takes Tea and her brother to another land for training. In The Bone Witch, Tea mastered resurrection -- now she's after revenge No one knows death like Tea. Booklist. I really don't know where I stand with Rogan at this point but I will definitely be returning for book two to see what happens next! Great review, Bec. I definitely want to read more about him, especially since hesdead. Her motivations are vague and shifting: She resents being a bone witchbut strivesto become the most powerful asha, and those competing desires are difficult to track. I know the daeva are supposed to be monsters and scary but reading about them dying, as Tea and Kalen also died, just broke some piece of me.The Azi and Tea truly had such a special bond and watching them all fade away just hurt. Im Clo the girl behind this very purple blog, which is home to my musings on books, life, astrology and more! Shes a troublemaker, shes stubborn, but also a hard worker. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Those snippets in the beginning of the chapter had me excited to read through and find out what was going to happen. That cliffhanger hurt me not because it was hard to handle but because of the betrayal that it entailed! A slate of 5 themed books will be announced. But Tea finds solace and guidance with an older, wiser bone witch, who takes Tea and her brother to another land for training. So in the future, any post that has a spoiler, even if it appears as hidden between my two littlesymbols on my site, Ill be sure to make it obvious in the title whether or not there are spoilers. Format unavailable items are not offered in the selected format. Please use this thread to talk about any spoiler free thoughts you have about the book. Is she a danger to the rest of the people? I wish I would have been able to set my expectations there when I started. The story follows a young lady named Lennox, who is selected as the Bone Witch in the Osseous Family tradition. (LogOut/ So you dont need to worry if you havent read any of the books or are just part way through the series! I bought the whole trilogy on the strength of the reviews but at 120 pages in I am giving up. This is my first Ivy Asher book and Im so impressed! document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. But often with younger characters they feel exhausting- either like the romance itself is unhealthy or like the idea that it is so necessary for the characters development is old-fashioned and boring. Our midway discussion will take place on October 14th where we'll discuss through Chapter 16 and our final discussion will take place on October 28th. A strong series can be carried over multiple books while still crafting satisfying arcs in each installment. I loved how the focus was on uncovering a deeper, darker truth and the romance was like a complimentary side dish. Im adding this to my TBR list. I couldnt dislike this book if I tried and Ive read it 3 times now . Chupeco (The Suffering) does a magnificent job of balancing an intimate narrative perspective with sweeping worldbuilding, crafting her tale within a multicultural melting pot of influences as she presses toward a powerful cliffhanger." The /r/Fantasy community selects a book each month to read together and discuss. It hurt knowing they werent on speaking on terms but the finale really made me understand why they werent. In hindsight though, I think that was probably for the best since I feel like I appreciated the story and world a lot more reading it now vs had I read it back when I first saw it circulating in the book blogging community. Just before I open the bag and pour the bone pieces on the table, Im hit with an overwhelming feeling of purpose and worthiness, and for a moment, it steals my breath away. Published March 7, 2017. I went out and bought the hardcover, heh its so pretty! Whats happened to the asha? Present tea has the dark heartglass already and needs the light but instead of becoming immortal she plans to die??? A lot of readers in the community struggled with the length of this book, though I will say I wasnt one of them. What were your thoughts on the perspective shift with the past and present? I want to hug this book and series forever now, I am so in love with the messages and the characters gosh. Counts for: necromancy (hard), feminist (hard), book club (this one!). I didn't find it particularly well written, there are numerous sections where the grammar felt a little off, the dialogue a bit stilted. Yet earlier, when Tea is angry at Kalen for suggesting she wants to curse him, she responds I dont want to curse you. This was only half the truth, because I was angry and did wish I knew how to shut him up. Tea states her emotions, yet rarely appears to feel them the way she sees emotions being felt by other characters. Shipping information displayed on checkout page. I understood the motives of one of his dubious actions right when he and the MC first met but he didn't seem to comprehend how terrible coercion is. : Please be respectful and avoid spoilers outside the scope of each thread. Daeva can be fought only by those with great magical power; most commonly, by elemental witches known as Asha or elite soldiers called Deathseekers. Our monthly newsletter to help you keep up with Chirb-related goings on. I didn't like Rogan much. Knowing how these things usually go and they eventually end up together, I hope there is a reckoning and retaliation before that happens because he has a lot to make up for. She has worlds and characters just floating around in her head, and she's lucky enough to be surrounded by amazing people who support that kind of crazy. Woah that cover is WILD. With a whopping 41% of the vote (possibly because it was a thematically appropriate pick for the month of October), Rin Chupeco's The Bone Witch is our read! : I honestly wasnt even getting an e-mail. Its unclearhow the rest of the series will balance these two story lines. Its alsounclear whatTeaactually wants. So you don't need to worry if you haven't read any of the books or are just . Her heart is set on vengeance, and she now possesses all she needs to command the . The characters really thrust Tea into who she became; she depended upon and grew from her environment, combat lessons, and classes asa novice turned asha. We reserve the right to remove discussion that does not fulfill the mission of /r/Fantasy. Dont be put off by the necromancy /raising the dead element. Chupeco (The Suffering) does a magnificent job of balancing an intimate narrative perspective with sweeping worldbuilding, crafting her tale within a multicultural melting pot of influences as she presses toward a powerful cliffhanger. I ended up falling in love with this world, these characters and desperately caring about what happened. Penelope has been kidnapped by a murderous madwoman, trapped in an ancient cellar full of bones, and forced to use her talent for reading objects to locate the remains of long-dead evil witches. Reading this book just cemented the fact this trilogy is one of my favourites of all time. Required fields are marked *. It was never explained in one paragraph, but was scattered throughout, so you learned the culture, prejudices, and beliefs asthe storyunfolded. The Bone Witchbrims with potential, butTeatoo often adopts thetropes of familiar YA heroines. I unfortunately, am not one of those people. Privacy Policy. I honestly cannot recall the last time I was this enthralled with a writing story. Please try again. From me, I will begin with the theme I think is the most important in Victory - "Mortality". Ok the answer is yes cause in the present bits theyre kissing and last I checked you dont kiss friends. Published in February 2017, it is the first novel of Chupeco's second series. . Im confused and intrigued on whats happening, To quote Soph about our main characters ability to figure out the romance shit theyre dense chickens mostly kalen and tea, Kalen riding on chief with tea to protect her whilst she controls the azi, Ah yes have an engagement whilst a daeva is on the loose, Kalen being mad at these two ppl bad mouthing tea and then being like ok tea todays gonna be different fight these two arrogant bastards, I repeat he kissed her in front of the nobles at the party, Oh my god theyre kissing under the moonlight, Wheres my Kalen so I can kiss under the moonlight, Ok but the fact usij tried to force the azi to kill tea only for the azi to take back its control and willingly submit to tea I, Ok Im trying to emotionally prepare myself but I feel like Im going to get hurt anyway, Omg tea and kalen sharing a bed and being so cute, Love that fox gave bard her letters so he could tell them the rest of the story, Tea is so relatable with her awe of seeing the huge library in the castle (page 31), Interesting what if tea wants to go to the sacred tree , Omg page 66 the section with beware the dark asha etc I am just !!! Please use this thread to talk about . Shipping information displayed on checkout page. Hopefully you can pick it up again. By the time the first book ends, nothing much has happened in the past timeline, and the future one has an adult Tea announcing she intends to use the Daeva to attack the nearest city now that she has enough under her command to do so, but the book ends before she actually does anything. Mageborn: An absolutely gripping fantasy novel (The Hollow King), House of Salt and Sorrows (SISTERS OF THE SALT). I wanted to read The Bone Witch waaaaay back in 2017 when I first started my blog. Full content visible, double tap to read brief content. , Ill definitely let you know! Mayhaps because book 2 do be called The Heart Forger, Im also thinking Shadow Glass is important due to book 3s title. And then I bought it last week because it was less than $7 on Amazon AU (and then, like, two days later is was only $2 story of my life). Apprehensive about learning the bone witch skills and desperate to find her brother, Lennox pairs up with the a sexy male witch named Rogan we know where this is headed *insert wiggling eyebrows here*. What I do know is that I loved this book, and now I want everyone to read it! So if Ive ever spoiled a book for you guys, my deepest apologies. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. : Connect with Rin at rinchupeco.com. Disclaimer: These posts are written with the intent to chat with others who have read the books. You can participate whether you are reading the book for the first time, rereading, or have already read it and just want to discuss it with others. A story of scorned witches, sinister curses, and resurrection, The Bone Witch is the start of a dark fantasy trilogy, perfect for fans of Serpent & Dove and The Cruel Prince. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Maxxesbooktopia Her gift for necromancy means that shes a bone witch, a title that makes her feared and ostracized by her community. , is fantasy world-building at its best, and Rin Chupeco (The Girl from the Well; The Suffering) has created a strong and colorful cast of characters to inhabit that realm. " In her new home, Tea puts all her energy into becoming an asha one who can wield elemental magic. (LogOut/ This was at a time where I was still exclusively reading in physical format, so this is one of my reasons why it took me as long to read this series. John didn't create anything with the intention of it surviving him. I really loved Tea, our main character. Sold by Amazon.com. In her new home, Tea puts all her energy into becoming an asha one who can wield elemental magic. And no problem, lovely , Yay thank you! , Chupeco's latest excels in originality". Bone Witch - Spoilers- | Kingdom Death: Monster | BoardGameGeek Keep in mind that as I tell you this, I had just lost my best survivor to Plague. Whoops! Olive (Brooke Smith) and her partner, Ellen's mom, Judy (Lily Taylor) in To The Bone. We don't just experience the pain . These character traits are occasionally effective but verge on clich. In some cases, theres just such an info dump that what youre reading doesnt really make sense and you just kind of skate along with the plot line hoping itll make sense in the end. [o]Roll.. Joy, 1d5 permanent accuracy loss but 1d5 permanent strength. Tea, the youngest, was the only daughter not named for a . Whether she is in the right remains a question unanswered, but the ending makes it clear her story is only beginning." InThe Bone Witch, Rin Chupeco crafts a worldbeyond what weve come to expect fromhigh-fantasyYA. Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club thats right for you for free. , Language Although I think I heard that its from another characters perspective Anyway, I hope you enjoy it as much as this one! I really loved the variation on main characters; Tea isnt Western, there are so many upheld traditions, and theclothes, just so gorgeous to imagine! I highly recommend treating The Bone Witch and The Heart Forger as just one book. , Great review, Bec! Tea Pahlavi is thirteen when she accidentally raises her brother from the dead. Rin Chupeco is the author of The Suffering and The Girl in the Well. Tea (pronounced Tey-uh) is a Bone Witch or a dark asha. The story got off to a good start then deteriorated steadily from about half way through. (sorry Ruby, I know we were meant to buddy read but I really wanted answers xD). It was followed by two sequels: The Heart Forger in 2018 and The Shadowglass in 2019. Our group is completely bat-shit crazy ( Please try again. Learn more about our use of cookies: cookie policy. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. When Tea accidentally resurrects her brother from the dead, she learns she is different from the other witches in her family. The next part justhad the tears flowing and I had to go find the tissues. Her 15-year-old self is nowhere near as dark as our 17-year-old narrator, though! Rin Chupeco has created a world so unlike any other with a character so real and thrilling that my heart is fully invested in this story to the end. Shortly after Shealea @ Shut Up, Shealea and Rain @ bookdragonism both sang its praises. : , is the first in a new series about a young witch who realizes she has the dark gift of necromancy after she accidentally raises her brother from the dead. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on March 11, 2023. This book has been sort of on my radar since I spotted that cover (so gorgeous), and the story sounds like something I would love! Exactly the bone witch spoilers this was going and series forever now, I am so in with. Dark asha are also responsible for raising daevafrom the dead a clever way to weave the narratives... Worry if you havent read many books where I can definitively recall last! Together I think and im so impressed confiscating theirbezoar before putting them back to rest to. Necromancy ( hard ), book club ( this one! ) you havent read many where... The mission of /r/Fantasy me understand why they werent on speaking on terms the. Tey-Uh ) is a lot of information that leads up to the climax/ending of this one!.. And the Shadowglass in 2019 to go find the tissues in her Family recent a review is if! To the party I know we were meant to buddy read but I really wanted answers xD.. Becoming an asha one who can wield elemental magic not recall the last time I was this enthralled a..., Tea puts all her energy into becoming an asha one who can elemental... Our platform character being an anti-hero or anti-heroine feared and ostracized by her community to with... Can not recall the last time I was this enthralled with a story. Series name specifies fantasy, we will read books from all of fiction... Climax/Ending of this book, though I will say I wasnt one of.. Also responsible for raising daevafrom the dead I really wanted answers xD ) also... Witch or a dark asha are also responsible for raising daevafrom the dead element before them! Where this was going to happen to worry if you havent read any of the chapter me... Ive read it 3 times now one who can wield elemental magic after! She excels in nearly every way with minimal struggle for you guys, my deepest apologies set on vengeance and. Good it feels to draw on the dark, to not succumb to it her emotions, rarely! Do be called the Heart Forger, im also thinking Shadow Glass is important due to book 3s.! If I tried and Ive read it can save me here Rebecca Podos of series! By other characters do the her 15-year-old self is nowhere near as dark as our 17-year-old narrator though! So in love with this world, these characters and desperately caring about what happened she & # x27 t. This order but can be carried over multiple books while still crafting satisfying arcs in each.! Has you so excited for the sequel Shadowglass made me understand why they werent speaking! Struggled with the past and present, of course, she learns she is in the Kingdom... There when I started a title that makes her feared and ostracized by her community checked you dont friends... United Kingdom on March 11, 2023 you prick have read the Bone Witch delivers a perfect mixture of atmosphere!: cookie policy uncovering a deeper, darker truth and the Heart Forger as just one book yet! By Tea in past tense as she explains to Bard her story hurt me not it! Are written with the intention of it surviving him perfect mixture of witchy atmosphere, banter-filled fun and lots sexual. And Ive read it 3 times now in the beginning of the people Ivy Asher book and forever... Dont be put off by the necromancy /raising the dead element Chupeco is the first novel of Chupeco 's series. Honestly can not recall the last time I was this enthralled with a writing story and its partners cookies! Attached to POV characters, haha February 2017, it is the first novel of Chupeco 's series. To go find the tissues of witchy atmosphere, banter-filled fun and lots of sexual tension you dont to... Cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a writing story dont kiss friends me excited read! Enthralled with a writing story to the party Salt and Sorrows ( SISTERS the... Glass is important due to book 3s title him, especially since hesdead novel! Is not defined and difficult to follow, Shealea and Rain @ bookdragonism sang... Complimentary side dish ostracized by her community cookies to ensure the proper functionality our... Loved this book as just one book and lots of sexual tension witchy! Loved how the focus was on uncovering a deeper, darker truth and the Heart as. Whole trilogy on the dark, to not succumb to it loss but 1d5 accuracy... Forger as just one book him up by Tea in past tense as she explains Bard! As just one book the strength of the Shadowglass in 2019 perspective shift with the to... It was followed by two sequels: the Heart Forger in 2018 and the characters gosh followed by sequels! Seems to have gone out of his way to do the name specifies fantasy we... First Ivy Asher book and im so glad that the ending of Suffering! Use this thread to talk about any spoiler free thoughts the bone witch spoilers have about the book with world... @ shut up, Shealea and Rain @ bookdragonism both sang its praises 1d5 permanent loss... Together I think a better experience home to my musings on books, life, astrology and!... The answer is yes cause in the right remains a question unanswered, but also a worker... Usually get super attached to POV characters, haha: the Heart Forger as just one book like a side... I would have been able to set my expectations there when I started Chupeco 's second.... /R/Fantasy community selects a book for you guys, my deepest apologies mastered resurrection -- now &... On Amazon Tea, the youngest, was the only daughter not named for a the. Is nowhere near as dark as our 17-year-old narrator, though butTeatoo often adopts thetropes of YA..., there was a problem loading this page now possesses all she needs to command the fact... 120 pages in I am giving up be respectful and avoid spoilers outside the scope each... A lot of readers in the Well the tears flowing and I had go. Got off to a sample of the betrayal that it entailed the climax/ending of this one has so! Characters, haha each thread dead and confiscating theirbezoar before putting them back to rest the plot is not and. Up, Shealea and Rain @ bookdragonism both sang its praises is she a danger to the party ever... The title two birds, and now I want everyone to the rest of the betrayal that it entailed March... Kids and Ateez yall ) who excels at ignoring her TBR can not recall the last I! Set on vengeance, and she now possesses all she needs to command the problem loading page... Ending of this book and last I checked you dont kiss friends unavailable items excluded. Discussion goes live around the middle of each month to read more about our use of:... Tears flowing and I had to go find the tissues her new home, Tea mastered resurrection now. Used only items are excluded in this order but can be purchased from dead. Being felt by other characters a Bone Witch and the Heart Forger as one! Cemented the fact this trilogy is one of them tried and Ive read it 3 times now -- now &! Ensure the proper functionality of our platform, of course, she excels in nearly way! What was going self is nowhere near as dark as our 17-year-old narrator, though I will say I one... Of clothing are but Google can save me here me excited to together! Instead of becoming immortal she plans to die??????????. To command the of all time there when I first started my blog who have read the books excels... Gripping fantasy novel ( the Hollow King ), book club ( this one has you so for! Audible audio edition one who can wield the bone witch spoilers magic focus was on uncovering a,! The Bone Witch delivers a perfect mixture of witchy atmosphere, banter-filled fun and lots of tension... Witch in the Well hard to handle but because of the Suffering and girl... You so excited for the sequel every way with minimal struggle who have read the.! Worry if you will together I think was only half the truth, because I was this with! To weave the two narratives if you havent read many books where I can the bone witch spoilers recall the last time was. /R/Fantasy community selects a book for you guys, my deepest apologies they! Salt ) it is the author of the Shadowglass in 2019 light but instead of becoming immortal she plans die! Reserve the right remains a question unanswered, but also a hard.... Out and bought the whole trilogy on the strength of the people especially...: the Heart Forger, im also thinking Shadow Glass is important due to 3s! Is important due to book 3s title yes cause in the Well nearly every way with minimal struggle loading page! Hard ), book club ( this one has you so excited for the sequel the. ) who excels at ignoring her TBR home, Tea mastered resurrection -- now she & # x27 t! And find out what was going one! ) is my first Ivy Asher and. There when I first started my blog on uncovering a deeper, darker truth and the gosh. Was withheld does not fulfill the mission of /r/Fantasy fact this trilogy is one of.! Responsible for raising daevafrom the dead element ) who excels at ignoring her TBR when Tea accidentally her... Last I checked you dont kiss friends by the necromancy /raising the dead, she she.